Textbook Evaluation BlogPost
The book, “Art: A Brief History” by Marilyn Stokstad and Michael Cothren, is both an interesting and well written book on the subject of art history, a subject frequently fraught with biased inaccuracies and dull definitions. Stokstad and Cothren attempt to avoid this by creating a product that is actually interesting, describing and analyzing societal, cultural, and religious background for works of art spanning the ages. There were many aspects of the book that made it more enjoyable for the audience. The combination of organization, readability, and eye pleasing formatting were three important aspects that made the book interesting. We believe the author’s goal was to create a book that is about art history more entertaining for readers while providing contextual background for historical works based on the cultures surrounding them. Without doubt, the author's intention was successful, but the book is still not perfect and could use some improvements.
Although the book attempts to avoid presenting biased or opinionated viewpoints of art, it still fails to present pieces equally in a manner devoid of cultural prejudices. One of the best examples of this can be seen by comparing the books presentation of two artworks, the first being a funerary vessel of Greek origin (Stokstad & Cothren, 103) and the second being a set of twin funerary statues, known as Ere Ibeji (Stokstad & Cothren, 440). Although the book explains the composition of both, the intended message and points drawn about the work differ. The vessel is used as an example of geometric style, with emphasis put on the composition and design of the artwork present on the pottery. The statues, however, are used as a learning piece to introduce the religious and spiritual customs of the Yoruba people of Nigeria. Although both are good explanations, it highlights the western viewpoint and cultures ingrained in the authors despite their attempts to avoid it. Further evidence of this can be found in the structure of the book, where frequently the western sections are divided into time periods where a specific artistic technique was invented or became popular while many eastern artworks are clumped together under their point of origin. The emphasis on technique, while important for both historical background and time period analysis, tends to overemphasize the western values of beauty rather than relying on the works underlying purpose and intention in contexts.
The authors attempt to avoid bias and even acknowledge its prevalence in the field as seen in the Arts and Its Context section (Stokstad & Cothren,434). Despite this, the bias ingrained in the field is hard to avoid due to long rooted beliefs inherited from western art historians over the centuries. In light of this, our team brainstormed possible changes to avoid these biases as well as general suggestions to enhance its value as a learning asset for the field of art history.
We think that the authors should include more art that is from different time periods. Most of the architectures, sculptures, paintings, buildings, cultures, etc. that are mentioned in this textbook are mainly from the ancient period (B.C to A.D). We think the authors should include modern artists and have them explain how their art relates with ancient art. If the authors included the thought process and inspiration of modern artist’s, it could show the audience how art has changed or stayed the same over time. It would also display the influential elements of ancient art. It is crucial for us to acknowledge the influence from ancient art because it shows how our ancestors were capable of creating something that could last decades.
One of the problems that we encountered is that the book contained a lack of diversity between different art regions. Most of the chapters were mainly about Western art with some chapters on non-Western art. With the lack of inclusion of non-Western art, people would slowly forget about other art cultures. These art cultures are important because they would provide many learning opportunities besides art. We could learn a lot about someone’s religion, culture, habits, etc. from studying their past art culture. There are still many amazing and unique architectures, artists, paintings, and sculptures from other regions that exist but are losing attention because of the immense concentration of western art. We think the authors should exclude some parts of the Western art or expand the book by including more non-Western art.
As previously mentioned, the organizational structure of the book tends to group artworks together by their relative geography. Although this creates a clear cut method of division which might benefit locations of origin sharing a similar artistic culture such as Europe, Ancient Greece, and Rome, it tends to create associations between different works which may have nothing in common other than a shared continental origin. As such we suggest including more sections or chapters based around central ideas or cultures which motivated the works. The book already has some chapters structured like this, such as chapters on Islamic art as well as early Christian and Jewish art. For example, including a chapter on Buddhism would better represent a large amount of works rather than lumping them together by origin.
Throughout the book a multitude of customs, cultures, and origins are discussed. For the most part, however, they are kept as individual topics and little time is spent discussing or comparing arts of different cultures. Calligraphy, for example, is mentioned in several different contexts including Chinese and Islamic art. The authors fail to compare and contrast the use of these techniques in different cultures, and in doing so fails to encompass the entirety of many subjects in a complete historical context. By including comparisons between artworks of different cultures, we can gain an understanding of intention and context in the creation of many works of art with less known background than others.
Overall, our assessment of the textbook is mixed for many reasons. Our issues with the work stem from the author’s structure and presentation of some parts while other sections are strongpoints which set the tone and capture the artwork in history, relying on its context and background to paint a whole new picture for the reader.
One of the strong suits of the book appears early on in the form of the Introduction. There the book attempts to help readers construct their own tools for analyzing and deconstructing artworks based on sociopolitical context and ideas of form and beauty which vary with both location and time setting. Approaching artworks while considering the contextual factors of creation such as the artist, their patrons, and their environment completely transforms the intentions and lessons we take away from them. This method of critically dissecting art as shown in figure 3 sets up viewers for a more open minded approach to a subject which spans a multitude of works, ideas, and viewpoints.
There are two lovely features that help make the entire book more compelling. One of the features is the “A Closer Look” section that is included throughout the book. This section only contains art such as paintings and sculptures. This is one of our favorite features in the book because this section has an image that is broken down with pointers. Every pointer contains details that help explain the image better. This would help the audience understand the image better without having any confusion. We would not have to guess which part of the image the author is describing or explaining. It also helps the reader have a longer attention span because the text is broken down into smaller paragraphs. The other feature is the section called “Elements of Architecture” which is something similar to the “A Closer Look” section. In these specific sections, only ancient architectures would be broken down with pointers. It would show the function and purpose of every aspect of an architecture. These two sections are really interesting and helpful while learning about art history.
It was thoughtful for Stokstad and Cothren to use mostly famous and well-known art as examples. Some of these artwork consists of The Last Supper by Leonardo da Vinci (figure 4), Hall of Bulls, Funerary Mask of Tutankhamun, The Stonehenge, and many other significant art. Utilizing famous art as a starting point and slowly transitioning to other unfamiliar art is a good strategic way to help readers understand better. The readers would recognize what they need to be wary of when viewing similar art. It would help people from being anxious when they initially begin learning about art history. Normally when people learn something new, they tend to be nervous because they do not have any prior experience. Overall, the authors have made it a better experience for their audience by including famous art.
On the negative end, much of the book is used as an acclamation of western artistic techniques. While works are frequently praised, the authors tend to romanticize the works of more prominent European artists while works from eastern or less “artistic” origins are described with an emphasis on materials or cultural backgrounds. While these are important, the contrast tends to bias the material unintentionally to a western viewpoint.
The goal of a global art history book is to capture the essence, purpose, and creation of art from a multitude of cultures throughout history. Stockstad and Cothren attempt this but miss the mark by focusing on the advancement of artistic technique, albeit important, rather than primarily focusing on the changing of ideas or cultures influencing the creation of art. This leads to a book bloated with every new European artistic technique rather than giving a complete representation of art through the ages. We believe that although many European shifts in ideas and culture in art are covered such as the gothic era and renaissance, the emphasis on the continent is disproportionate to the actual portion of art history it embodies. This does not necessarily detract from the validity or value of the book as a resource, but does detract from its claim of being a “brief history of art”.
No single art history book can cover the entirety of the subject. Humans have limitless creativity and potential for new ideas and techniques to express themselves, something that doesn't change no matter the era. The role of book writers in the field is to attempt to encapsulate and present the ideas and values that mark important aspects of art history, not just its development. We believe Stokstad and Cothren, in order to improve their book, must ask themselves just how influential and relevant some of the chosen works are for art history, and compare them to less represent aspects and cultures of art across the world.
Just as art is prevalent throughout history, the influence it has on us today is engrained in our society and culture. In an effort to solidify our skills learned through the textbook and class lectures, we each explored our surroundings to identify and analyze local buildings which reflect some of the history we learned about. Below are our attempts to connect the history of art we studied and the world we experience every day.
This is an image of San Francisco City Hall taken from the side. The building is similar to the classical architectural design that was used in ancient Greek buildings. We could see triglyphs (Vertical plaques which are mostly grouped in three that could be found towards the roof of an architecture) near the top of the building that extends around the entire building. Looking closely at the image, it seems that Doric order was used for the columns. Doric order was one of the main three architectural order designs used on classical buildings. The simplicity of the Doric order design is what makes the building so special by adding a elegant vibe.
In a town mostly constructed of economically constructed square beige buildings, the Simi Valley Cultural Arts Center attempts to set itself apart with more unique construction with elements dating back to Ancient Greece. The columns, for example, mimic similarities of Doric order, while the two near the entrance are crowned by carvings of Acanthus leaves commonly found carved in Corinthian pillars. The layout of the entrance including the semicircular areas surrounded by seating contain elements of Greek amphitheaters. The several windows with stained glass draw parallels to Christian churches, a technique especially popular during the gothic era.
Outside the Los Angeles County Museum of Art (LACMA), there are the Urban Lights on the sidewalk. These lights were influenced by ancient Greek architecture. The lights are supported by pillars which are made up of different pillar styles. Most of the lights in the front could be considered Doric style, while the inside pillars are a mix of both Ionic and Corinthian style. Although they don’t look exactly the same, the use of ancient Greek pillar styles is visible.
Overall, “Art: A Brief History”, is a textbook which focuses on the history of artworks from many places of the world and their different time periods. The textbook has accomplished our understanding of the meaning behind specific art and how it influenced other generations throughout time. This is due to the emphasis on Western art. The comparison of both artworks used for something the same is an example of how the textbook puts a spotlight on the technique in Western art, while putting a spotlight on religion and meaning on nonwestern art. We would recommend this book to anyone that is interested in art history, specifically, people who want to learn more about western art. However, if you’d like to learn more on non-western art, we do not recommend this book since the majority of this book is on western art. All in all, this is a wonderful book for anyone that is interested to get into art history.
Word Count - 2302
Great blog with a very detailed analysis of the textbook
ReplyDeleteVery well laid out and interesting blog. Good job. -Mireya Arana
ReplyDeleteGreat commentary, i never thought of how the structure of the book and how pieces were grouped geographically as a point of bias.
ReplyDeleteInteresting information that was provided in this blogpost, I enjoyed reading your approaches towards the textbook and its focuses
ReplyDeleteThe art detectives were really cool! I never thought of the LA lights being influenced by greek architecture, very interesting. -Nikki Phan
ReplyDeletegreat detail and examples for analysis- Janessa Gomez
ReplyDeleteAwesome work, loved the detail in which you all put in the analysis!
ReplyDelete- Justin Ya
This project had really nice points of contextual evidence throughout the piece. It appeared that the sections weren't labeled so as a viewer, I wasn't quite sure what part was which. - Jade Woodworth
ReplyDeleteI love how you guys each chose examples that are here in California. It's crazy to think we are surrounded by all kinds of artwork. -Julinna Fletes
ReplyDeletereally good analysis of the book that was easy to follow! loved the art you all chose for your detectives section, really cool to see familiar places!
ReplyDeletevery detailed and expansive on the analysis on the textbook, great job -Gabe De Pina
ReplyDeleteYou guys really put in effort with your analysis and your art detectives, It looks professional.
ReplyDeletegreat blog post, it was very well detailed and had great art work. -araceli
ReplyDeleteI love that you chose the art installation at LACMA, it's one of my favorites!
ReplyDeleteYour ideas and thoughts were expressed so well and it is clear that you all put in effort to get them across to your audience. The organization was well and easy to follow as well. Good work!
ReplyDeleteThe analysis of the textbook was good, and the greek influence on LA's buildings is quite interesting.
ReplyDeleteI thought that the work was done well but adding titles to the new section of writing could help boost the effect of the blog ~ Brennan Garcia
ReplyDeleteWow! Amazing work! I love the LACMA contribution as well! It is literally so gorgeous!
ReplyDeleteA very thorough analysis in this blog post, goes into great detail and provides great photos.
ReplyDelete-Ivan Vargas
Nice informative post. I loved how you guys were able to connect the relevance of Greek architecture to today's buildings.
ReplyDeleteI loved the images that you guys chose for the art detectives section. You guys did a great job in the analysis section. Nice Job! - Lucero Ascencio
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed the introduction paragraph and the way the rest of the blog flowed together, the placement of the images was great as well.
ReplyDelete- Lisset Ochoa
DeleteWe really liked how the paragraphs were divided, making this a super easy and coherent read. The art detectives are really cool too, nice analysis. - Katerina, Clarissa, and Amber
ReplyDeleteI love the comparison and how well in depth it is!
ReplyDeleteThe figures mentioned did not have "()". Other than that, the simple white background made the text easy to read.
ReplyDeleteThe analysis of the book was well thought out, nice job -Jessica Zepeda
ReplyDeleteI also agree that this book is not helpful for those seeking to gain knowledge on non-Western art. -Cristina Molina
ReplyDeleteI liked that you included the layout of the book and how it presents info in your analysis.
ReplyDeleteI really like the format of the blog post and the pictures. The pictures chosen gave an extra touch to details withing your blog post.
ReplyDeleteI liked how it is so detailed and organized. Great job!
ReplyDeleteI liked how you pointed out the flaw of the book focusing a lot on western techniques. -Stefania Ortiz
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed the analysis of the artwork comparisons as well as the overall textbook analysis.
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed the blog post overall! Really great explanations!- Violeta Gamboa
ReplyDeleteI like how there was a common theme of local architecture for all the art detectives, it made it feel very cohesive
ReplyDeleteReally like the analysis about the how the textbook are very opinionated and the evidence you used to to support it.
ReplyDeleteI was interested by your discussion of the “A Closer Look” and “Elements of Architecture” sections. Great analysis!
ReplyDelete(Above is commented by Anthony Michel)
DeleteIris Gutierrez: I love how in-depth the analysis of the textbook and artworks were.
ReplyDeleteI enjoy reading about how Simi Valley Cultural Arts Center shares Doric order and Corinthian pillars, thanks for sharing how modern art is inspired by many ancient art techniques, pretty cool blog :)
ReplyDeleteI like how you mentioned they clump up artistic movements into regions
ReplyDelete